Lily LakeResort Call (262) 537-2848
Front of the Lily Lake Resort building, a hotel since the early 1900s

Since the Early 1900s

About Lily Lake Resort

A beach, the Sunset Grill and ten rooms on a clear, spring-fed lake.

Lily Lake Resort main building and deck from the lawn

Our Story

More Than a Hundred Years on the Lake

For over a century, Lily Lake Resort has happily hosted vacationing families and outdoor enthusiasts with friendly hearts and lots of charm. This building has been a hotel since the early 1900s. Ask anyone who's found us and you'll hear the same two words: hidden gem.

We're on the shore of Lily Lake in the Town of Wheatland, next door to the New Munster Wildlife Area. Today it's a beach, the Sunset Grill, our Lily Lake tavern, and ten rooms, open year-round. Neighbors from Milwaukee and Chicago are frequent visitors, and we've hosted travelers from across the country and around the world. A vacation destination for all four seasons. We promise you'll feel right at home!

Jill, owner of Lily Lake Resort

Meet Jill

The Owner, and Often the Cook

Jill has owned and run Lily Lake Resort for more than 20 years, and she makes a lot of the specials on the chalkboard at the Sunset Grill herself. When there's no cook in the kitchen, you'll find Jill at the stove.

"Jill's Thrill" written in the concrete
"Jill's Thrill," written in the concrete.
Jill holding a cake that reads "Good Job Jill, you made it 20 years"
Jill's 20-year cake, November 2024.
5 out of 5 stars
“Jilly is awesome & her fish fry IS the best!!”
Traci · Google review · 2023

4.5 average from 567 reviews on Google as of November 2026

Read them all on Google → · Been here? Leave a review →

Take a Break at Lily Lake.

Follow Us on Facebook

Specials, live music and event dates go up there first. Join 7,700+ neighbors and regulars. 94% recommend us on Facebook (806 reviews).

Before You Go

Never Miss a Special

What's on the chalkboard, the Friday Fish Fry and the next band, party or event at the Sunset Grill.

We only email about Lily Lake. Unsubscribe anytime. Form not loading? Sign up here.